I was aid to `Ali (AS), “A man speaks about Divine Will.” He (AS) said: “Call him to me.” The reported says: So he was called to his presence. Thus, Imam `Ali (AS) asked him, “O servant of Allah, did Allah create you out of His Will or out of your will?” He replied, “Out of His own Will.” He (AS) asked, “Does he make you ill when He wishes or when you wish?” He answered, “When He wishes.” He (AS) questioned, “Does He cure you when He wishes or when you wish?” He responded, “When He wishes.” He (AS) enquired, “Does he make you enter (this world) as He wishes or as you wish?” He answered, “As He wishes.” Hence, Ali (AS) said to him, “If you had said other than this, I would have hit your neck.